Study: Most Wikipedia articles about medical conditions contain - KAIT Jonesboro, AR - Region 8 News, weather, sports

Study: Most Wikipedia articles about medical conditions contain errors

JONESBORO, AR (KAIT) - Doctors said relying on Wikipedia for medical information is a mistake.

A research article in the Journal of the American Osteopathic Association compared Wikipedia to medical journals and found major flaws in articles regarding diabetes, high blood pressure, lung cancer and more.

People expect a simple Google search to give them a correct answer, but one local doctor said just because it's quick, does not mean it's right.

"Everybody uses Wikipedia and everybody uses Google, but it's not the place to go for your health care needs," said Dr. Shane Speights with St. Bernards Medical Center. 

The research article did not give specifics but stated the biggest flaws in the Wikipedia articles were in how patients should manage and treat the medical conditions.

"If individuals start looking up high blood pressure and diabetes and start assuming that's all fact in there, that would be a mistake," Dr. Speights said.

He said people then make bad decisions based on bad medical information.  

"When it comes to your health care, you want the right answer, not the quickest," Dr. Speights said. 

To test the article's results, Dr. Speights looked up another major medical condition that was not included in the study: Ebola.

"I Google Ebola and the second one is Wikipedia," he said. "That's the first one people click on because they think, 'Well, it's the easiest and maybe it's the best.'"

But Dr. Speights said that's wrong. He noticed errors early on in the Wikipedia article on Ebola.

"I don't know about this, where they sited it," he said. "They sited the New York Times Magazine. We don't do that."

Dr. Speights said doctors never cite newspaper articles, rather journal articles and studies.

"So even on Ebola, just in this quick review here, we found this is not referenced correctly," he said. "They try to cite it but they can't verify all of those. You're talking about hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of entries in Wikipedia. There's no way that humans can sit down, go through all of those and verify that information with any significant accuracy."

Dr. Speights said people can find better information by taking a few more seconds to scroll down the Google search results page.

"It's going to be right here at the CDC," he said. "That's a reputable website. It's fifth down the page."

Dr. Speights said the following websites are reputable sources that he would recommend using for medical information: the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, World Health Organization and New England Journal of Medicine. 

"They're actually going to look at the information and make sure that there is good, reliable facts behind the information they post," he said.

Ultimately, Dr. Speights said if people have a question regarding a medical condition, instead of asking Google, ask a doctor. 

Copyright 2014 KAIT. All rights reserved.

  • Region 8 News</span><a class="customMoreLink" href="/Global/category.asp?C=4391" target="_top">More >></a>Region 8 NewsMore>>

  • breaking

    Police chief releases names in officer-involved shooting

    Police chief releases names in officer-involved shooting

    Saturday, December 16 2017 9:57 PM EST2017-12-17 02:57:14 GMT
    Sunday, December 17 2017 10:27 PM EST2017-12-18 03:27:05 GMT
    Arkansas State Police investigators are looking into an officer involved shooting Saturday night. (Source: KAIT)Arkansas State Police investigators are looking into an officer involved shooting Saturday night. (Source: KAIT)

    An officer-involved shooting Saturday night in Independence County will be investigated by the Arkansas State Police, officials said Sunday morning. 

    An officer-involved shooting Saturday night in Independence County will be investigated by the Arkansas State Police, officials said Sunday morning. 

  • Kids receive Christmas gifts Saturday

    Kids receive Christmas gifts Saturday

    Sunday, December 17 2017 5:19 PM EST2017-12-17 22:19:23 GMT
    Sunday, December 17 2017 8:38 PM EST2017-12-18 01:38:10 GMT
    Mark Martin purchases a teddy bear Saturday for a child as part of the Sharp County Shop with a Cop program. (Source: Sharp County Shop with a Cop Facebook Page)Mark Martin purchases a teddy bear Saturday for a child as part of the Sharp County Shop with a Cop program. (Source: Sharp County Shop with a Cop Facebook Page)

    At least 130 children in Sharp County will have a brighter Christmas after an event Saturday at the Walmart in Ash Flat. 

    At least 130 children in Sharp County will have a brighter Christmas after an event Saturday at the Walmart in Ash Flat. 

  • Hoxie Fire Department looks to buy new truck

    Hoxie Fire Department looks to buy new truck

    Sunday, December 17 2017 6:27 PM EST2017-12-17 23:27:27 GMT
    Sunday, December 17 2017 8:34 PM EST2017-12-18 01:34:50 GMT
    Hoxie firefighters are looking to purchase a rescue pumper truck for the department. (Source: KAIT)Hoxie firefighters are looking to purchase a rescue pumper truck for the department. (Source: KAIT)

    Hoxie firefighters are working to build the infrastructure they need to battle fires as well as reduce the ISO rating for their department. 

    Hoxie firefighters are working to build the infrastructure they need to battle fires as well as reduce the ISO rating for their department. 

Powered by Frankly