Judge allows lawsuit on life-ending drugs for terminally ill - KAIT Jonesboro, AR - Region 8 News, weather, sports

Judge allows lawsuit on life-ending drugs for terminally ill

(AP Photo/Carl Costas, File). FILE - In this Sept. 11, 2015 file photo, Debbie Ziegler, mother of Brittany Maynard, speaks to the media after the passage of legislation, which would allow terminally ill patients to legally end their lives, at the state... (AP Photo/Carl Costas, File). FILE - In this Sept. 11, 2015 file photo, Debbie Ziegler, mother of Brittany Maynard, speaks to the media after the passage of legislation, which would allow terminally ill patients to legally end their lives, at the state...
(AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File). FILE - In this Friday, June 9, 2017 file photo, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra speaks during an interview with The Associated Press, in Sacramento, Calif. A Riverside County judge on Friday, June 16, is ex... (AP Photo/Rich Pedroncelli, File). FILE - In this Friday, June 9, 2017 file photo, California Attorney General Xavier Becerra speaks during an interview with The Associated Press, in Sacramento, Calif. A Riverside County judge on Friday, June 16, is ex...
By AMY TAXIN
Associated Press

RIVERSIDE, Calif. (AP) - A judge on Friday allowed a legal challenge to proceed against California's law letting terminally ill patients seek prescriptions for life-ending drugs.

Riverside County Superior Court Judge Daniel A. Ottolia ruled that a group of doctors had provided sufficient information for a lawsuit over the 2016 law allowing medically-assisted death.

California's Attorney General Xavier Becerra had argued that the suit should be dismissed because doctors aren't bound to issue these prescriptions and the law merely offers patients a choice. But Ottolia found that the plaintiffs had alleged enough information to argue that the law violates the state's constitution by treating terminally ill people distinctly from others contemplating taking their lives.

"This is a violation of both the equal protection and due process clause of the constitution," plaintiffs' attorney Stephen Larson told reporters after the ruling.

California is one of a number of states where terminally ill patients can get prescriptions to take life-ending drugs, along with Oregon, Washington, Vermont and Montana.

The law took effect in California in June 2016. It was approved a year earlier but couldn't take effect until the conclusion of a special session on health care.

To take advantage of the law, patients must be given six months or less to live, make two verbal requests at least 15 days apart and submit a written request.

During a hearing in Riverside, Deputy Attorney General Kathleen Lynch argued that the law has many safeguards and the plaintiffs - which include doctors and the American Academy of Medical Ethnics - were making allegations based on hypothetical situations.

"This Act takes nothing from anybody," she told the court. "It gives terminally ill people a right."

A trial setting conference was scheduled for Oct. 20.

The law passed following the heavily publicized case of a 29-year-old California woman with brain cancer who moved to Oregon to legally end her life in 2014.

Some see the measure as providing a choice to the dying in a health care system that helps people live longer but is limited in preventing slow, painful deaths. Critics say they fear the option will lead to hasty decisions, misdiagnosis and waning support for palliative care.

In the last year, at least 504 terminally ill Californians have requested the prescriptions, according to advocacy group Compassion & Choices. The number includes only those who contacted the organization. The state has not released official data.

Kevin Diaz, the organization's national director of legal advocacy, said he was disappointed but doubted the challenge would succeed.

"It is unfortunate they're trying to impose their beliefs on people who are suffering unbearably at the end of life," he told reporters.

Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • National SportsMore>>

  • Ellsbury ties odd Rose mark for most catcher's interference

    Ellsbury ties odd Rose mark for most catcher's interference

    Wednesday, June 28 2017 12:05 AM EDT2017-06-28 04:05:13 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 2:35 AM EDT2017-06-28 06:35:53 GMT
    Jacoby Ellsbury of the New York Yankees has tied Pete Rose's obscure record for reaching base the most times in a career on catcher's interference.Ellsbury did it for the 29th time when his bat tipped the mitt of...
    Jacoby Ellsbury of the New York Yankees has tied Pete Rose's obscure record for reaching base the most times in a career on catcher's interference.Ellsbury did it for the 29th time when his bat tipped the mitt of Chicago White Sox catcher Kevan Smith.
  • Florida beats LSU 6-1 at CWS for 1st national championship

    Florida beats LSU 6-1 at CWS for 1st national championship

    Tuesday, June 27 2017 11:43 PM EDT2017-06-28 03:43:50 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 2:35 AM EDT2017-06-28 06:35:51 GMT
    (AP Photo/Matt Ryerson). Florida pitcher Tyler Dyson, center, is congratulated by teammates after being relieved during the seventh inning against LSU in Game 2 of the NCAA College World Series baseball finals in Omaha, Neb., Tuesday, June 27, 2017.(AP Photo/Matt Ryerson). Florida pitcher Tyler Dyson, center, is congratulated by teammates after being relieved during the seventh inning against LSU in Game 2 of the NCAA College World Series baseball finals in Omaha, Neb., Tuesday, June 27, 2017.

    Florida breaks open the game in 8th inning, and beats LSU 6-1 for its first national title in baseball.

    Florida breaks open the game in 8th inning, and beats LSU 6-1 for its first national title in baseball.

  • Maeda dominates in spot start, Dodgers beat Angels 4-0

    Maeda dominates in spot start, Dodgers beat Angels 4-0

    Wednesday, June 28 2017 1:03 AM EDT2017-06-28 05:03:54 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 2:35 AM EDT2017-06-28 06:35:46 GMT
    Kenta Maeda pitched four-hit ball over seven innings in a spot start, Joc Pederson hit a three-run homer and the Los Angeles Dodgers beat the Angels 4-0 at Dodger Stadium.
    Kenta Maeda pitched four-hit ball over seven innings in a spot start, Joc Pederson hit a three-run homer and the Los Angeles Dodgers beat the Angels 4-0 at Dodger Stadium.
  • NationalMore>>

  • Michael Moore donates $10,000 to Shakespeare in the Park

    Michael Moore donates $10,000 to Shakespeare in the Park

    Wednesday, June 28 2017 3:04 AM EDT2017-06-28 07:04:00 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 3:06 AM EDT2017-06-28 07:06:05 GMT
    Filmmaker Michael Moore, who is making his Broadway debut this summer in a solo show, will donate $10,000 to Shakespeare in the Park after it lost funding from sponsors due to the controversial "Julius Caesar"...
    Filmmaker Michael Moore, who is making his Broadway debut this summer in a solo show, will donate $10,000 to Shakespeare in the Park after it lost funding from sponsors due to the controversial "Julius Caesar" production.
  • Utah officials blame lack of logging for major wildfire

    Utah officials blame lack of logging for major wildfire

    Tuesday, June 27 2017 2:13 AM EDT2017-06-27 06:13:15 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 3:06 AM EDT2017-06-28 07:06:04 GMT
    The nation's largest wildfire has forced more than 1,500 people from their homes and cabins in a southern Utah mountain area home to a ski town and popular fishing lake. Crews in California, meanwhile, are dealing...
    The nation's largest wildfire has forced more than 1,500 people from their homes and cabins in a southern Utah mountain area home to a ski town and popular fishing lake. Crews in California, meanwhile, are dealing with two new powerful fires.
  • Sarah Palin sues paper for tying her PAC ad to mass shooting

    Sarah Palin sues paper for tying her PAC ad to mass shooting

    Tuesday, June 27 2017 8:43 PM EDT2017-06-28 00:43:46 GMT
    Wednesday, June 28 2017 3:05 AM EDT2017-06-28 07:05:55 GMT
    Former Alaska governor Sarah Palin is accusing The New York Times of defamation over an editorial that linked one of her political action committee ads to the mass shooting that severely wounded then-Arizona...
    Former Alaska governor Sarah Palin is accusing The New York Times of defamation over an editorial that linked one of her political action committee ads to the mass shooting that severely wounded then-Arizona Congresswoman Gabby Giffords.
Powered by Frankly