Wisconsin high court sides with fired conservative professor - KAIT Jonesboro, AR - Region 8 News, weather, sports

Wisconsin high court sides with fired conservative professor

(Mike De Sisti/Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel via AP, File). FILE - In this May 2, 2016, file photo Marquette University professor John McAdams speaks at a news conference in Milwaukee. The Wisconsin Supreme Court is expected to rule Friday, July 6, 2018, ... (Mike De Sisti/Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel via AP, File). FILE - In this May 2, 2016, file photo Marquette University professor John McAdams speaks at a news conference in Milwaukee. The Wisconsin Supreme Court is expected to rule Friday, July 6, 2018, ...

By IVAN MORENO
Associated Press

MILWAUKEE (AP) - A former Marquette University professor who wrote a blog post criticizing a student instructor he believed shut down debate against gay marriage shouldn't have lost his job because of what he published, the Wisconsin Supreme Court ruled Friday.

The 120-page decision concluded that the private Catholic school breached its contract with professor John McAdams that guaranteed academic freedom and that he should be immediately reinstated. The university said it would comply with the ruling.

The court's 4-2 decision came down on ideological lines, with the conservative majority siding with McAdams. Those justices said the faculty panel that recommended his discipline had an "unacceptable bias" because one member had publicly expressed support for the graduate instructor.

The liberal justices called the decision "far reaching" and said academic freedom "does not protect McAdams from discipline" if his peers concluded he acted unprofessionally. One justice didn't participate in the ruling.

McAdams sued the university in 2016, arguing that he lost his job for exercising freedom of speech. Marquette said he wasn't fired for the content of his 2014 post, but because he named the instructor and linked to her personal website that had personal identifying information.

"That's not academic freedom. That's cyberbullying," Ralph Weber, Marquette's attorney, said Friday.

The instructor, a graduate student, later received a flood of hateful messages and threats, and at one point needed a security guard stationed outside her class. She eventually moved to another university where she had to repeat three semesters and revise her Ph.D. thesis.

The case has been closely watched by conservatives who see universities as liberal havens, as well as private businesses that want control over employee discipline.

In the November 2014 blog post, McAdams described an interaction between a conservative student and a graduate student instructor of philosophy. The student claimed the instructor refused to allow discussion about opposition to gay marriage during a class and provided McAdams with a recording he secretly made of a conversation with the teacher after the class.

That formed the basis for McAdams' post, in which he argued that the students' experience was another example of liberals silencing people whose opinions they disagree with or find offensive. The post included the student-teacher's name, a link to her personal website and her email address.

In its Friday ruling, the court's conservative majority said McAdams' blog post can't be blamed for the harassment against the instructor.

"Just because vile commentary followed the blog post does not mean the blog post instigated or invited the vileness," the majority's written opinion said.

Liberal justices who dissented said conservatives ignored the fact that McAdams promoted his post to national media outlets knowing the backlash the student could receive, once writing that when something gets widespread attention, it's possible "some jerks are going to say nasty things."

"McAdams indeed did 'instigate' or 'invite' the vileness that followed his blog post. He knew what would happen, and he actively ensured that it would happen," the dissenting justices wrote. They called McAdams' behavior reckless and contrary to the university's professional standards.

McAdams' attorney, Rick Esenberg, said he disagreed with the liberal justices' conclusion that academic freedom shouldn't protect the professor from discipline.

"I think it's just flat wrong. The whole purpose of academic freedom is to allow people in the university community to express themselves without fear of sanctions," he said.

He said McAdams intends to teach again at Marquette, though it's unclear when that will happen.

McAdams published his post on his personal website, "Marquette Warrior," which he has used for more than a decade to condemn political correctness and the silencing of ideas that might be hurtful to protected classes, according to his lawsuit against the school.

McAdams was given the chance to return to work after his suspension, provided he write a letter apologizing for his conduct. The letter was to be shared confidentially with the student instructor, but McAdams refused to write it.

___

For the latest information on this story: www.apnews.com/850642597e58465a94f5bb6451adf184

___

Follow Ivan Moreno on Twitter: https://twitter.com/IvanJourno

Copyright 2018 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

  • National SportsMore>>

  • LEADING OFF: Cards' Carpenter on tear, deGrom wants to stay

    LEADING OFF: Cards' Carpenter on tear, deGrom wants to stay

    Friday, July 20 2018 10:11 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:11:43 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:19 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:19:08 GMT
    (AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast). St. Louis Cardinals' Matt Carpenter celebrates his second home run of the game off Chicago Cubs starting pitcher Jon Lester during the second inning of a baseball game Friday, July 20, 2018, in Chicago.(AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast). St. Louis Cardinals' Matt Carpenter celebrates his second home run of the game off Chicago Cubs starting pitcher Jon Lester during the second inning of a baseball game Friday, July 20, 2018, in Chicago.
    LEADING OFF: Cards' Carpenter on tear, Mets' deGrom wants to stay, record heat in Texas for Bartolo.
    LEADING OFF: Cards' Carpenter on tear, Mets' deGrom wants to stay, record heat in Texas for Bartolo.
  • Guatemalan pleads guilty in crash that killed Colts player

    Guatemalan pleads guilty in crash that killed Colts player

    Friday, July 20 2018 5:58 PM EDT2018-07-20 21:58:55 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:18 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:18:55 GMT
    (Indiana State Police via AP, File). FILE - This file photo provided by the Indiana State Police shows Manuel Orrego-Savala, of Guatemala. Orrego-Savala, living illegally in the U.S., pleaded guilty Friday, July 20, 2018, to driving drunk when he kille...(Indiana State Police via AP, File). FILE - This file photo provided by the Indiana State Police shows Manuel Orrego-Savala, of Guatemala. Orrego-Savala, living illegally in the U.S., pleaded guilty Friday, July 20, 2018, to driving drunk when he kille...
    A Guatemalan man living illegally in the U.S. has pleaded guilty to driving drunk when he killed Indianapolis Colts linebacker Edwin Jackson and his Uber driver.
    A Guatemalan man living illegally in the U.S. has pleaded guilty to driving drunk when he killed Indianapolis Colts linebacker Edwin Jackson and his Uber driver.
  • Sagan takes third win at Tour, Thomas keeps lead on Stage 13

    Sagan takes third win at Tour, Thomas keeps lead on Stage 13

    Friday, July 20 2018 11:47 AM EDT2018-07-20 15:47:33 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:18 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:18:53 GMT
    Peter Sagan won his third stage at this year's Tour de France on Friday, while Geraint Thomas kept the overall lead over teammate Chris Froome.
    Peter Sagan won his third stage at this year's Tour de France on Friday, while Geraint Thomas kept the overall lead over teammate Chris Froome.
  • NationalMore>>

  • The Latest: Senator considering legislation on duck boats

    The Latest: Senator considering legislation on duck boats

    Friday, July 20 2018 1:36 AM EDT2018-07-20 05:36:02 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:19 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:19:37 GMT
    (Andrew Jansen/The Springfield News-Leader via AP). Rescue crews work at the scene of a deadly boat accident at Table Rock Lake in Branson, Mo., Thursday, July 19, 2018. A sheriff in Missouri said a tourist boat has apparently capsized on the lake, lea...(Andrew Jansen/The Springfield News-Leader via AP). Rescue crews work at the scene of a deadly boat accident at Table Rock Lake in Branson, Mo., Thursday, July 19, 2018. A sheriff in Missouri said a tourist boat has apparently capsized on the lake, lea...
    A Missouri sheriff says at least 11 people have now been confirmed dead after a boat carrying tourists on a lake in a popular vacation city capsized and sank.
    A Missouri sheriff says at least 11 people have now been confirmed dead after a boat carrying tourists on a lake in a popular vacation city capsized and sank.
  • NYC releases documents connected to Central Park 5 case

    NYC releases documents connected to Central Park 5 case

    Friday, July 20 2018 8:51 AM EDT2018-07-20 12:51:26 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:19 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:19:19 GMT
    (AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this Jan. 17, 2012 file photo, Yusef Salaam, left, Kevin Richardson, second left, and Raymond Santana, right, react to supporters in New York. The three men who were exonerated in the 1989 Central Park Jogg...(AP Photo/Frank Franklin II, File). FILE - In this Jan. 17, 2012 file photo, Yusef Salaam, left, Kevin Richardson, second left, and Raymond Santana, right, react to supporters in New York. The three men who were exonerated in the 1989 Central Park Jogg...
    New York City has started releasing about 100,000 pages of documents connected to the notorious case of the five men whose convictions for raping and beating a Central Park jogger were overturned after they served...
    New York City has started releasing about 100,000 pages of documents connected to the notorious case of the five men whose convictions for raping and beating a Central Park jogger were overturned after they served more than a decade behind bars.
  • Colorado VA hospital plagued by delays, high costs to open

    Colorado VA hospital plagued by delays, high costs to open

    Friday, July 20 2018 3:05 PM EDT2018-07-20 19:05:09 GMT
    Friday, July 20 2018 10:19 PM EDT2018-07-21 02:19:11 GMT
    (AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File). FILE - In this June 8, 2017, file photo, the campus of the Veterans Administration hospital is under construction in Aurora, Colo. The center is set to open Saturday, July 21, 2018, years behind schedule and more than...(AP Photo/David Zalubowski, File). FILE - In this June 8, 2017, file photo, the campus of the Veterans Administration hospital is under construction in Aurora, Colo. The center is set to open Saturday, July 21, 2018, years behind schedule and more than...
    It's more than $1 billion over budget and five years behind schedule, but an elaborate new veterans hospital is finally opening in suburban Denver with the promise of state-of-the-art medical care.
    It's more than $1 billion over budget and five years behind schedule, but an elaborate new veterans hospital is finally opening in suburban Denver with the promise of state-of-the-art medical care.
Powered by Frankly